ADVERTISEMENT
  • 5-Minute to cure Knee pain
  • Abaout Us
  • Blood Flow
  • Child Growth
  • Child Learning
  • Contact Us
  • Custom keto diet
  • Disclaimer
  • DMCA
  • Dog Traning
  • Earn Easy
  • FatBurning
  • Herpes Virus
  • Home
  • kito diet
  • Leptitox strive
  • Privacy Policy
  • Resurge
  • SmoothyDiet
  • TedsWoodWorking
Saturday, March 6, 2021
HealthyKnock.Com
No Result
View All Result
  • Login
  • Home
  • Diet & Fitness
  • Other
  • New York Times
  • UK News
  • माँ के नुस्खे
  • self-care
  • mental-health
  • feminine-hygiene
  • weight-loss
  • Home
  • Diet & Fitness
  • Other
  • New York Times
  • UK News
  • माँ के नुस्खे
  • self-care
  • mental-health
  • feminine-hygiene
  • weight-loss
No Result
View All Result
Healthyknock.com
No Result
View All Result
ADVERTISEMENT
Home New York Times

Opinion | Amy Coney Barrett and the New, Old Anti-Catholicism

mohit by mohit
September 26, 2020
in New York Times
0
Opinion | Amy Coney Barrett and the New, Old Anti-Catholicism
0
SHARES
3
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT


Ms. Barrett has meditated on this matter herself, as a co-author of a 1998 law review article addressing this genre of conundrum. The essay considers the options of Catholic judges hearing capital punishment cases, which the state permits but the church forbids. Ms. Barrett and her co-author maintain that Catholic judges must or should recuse themselves from such cases, concluding that “judges cannot — nor should they try to — align our legal system with the Church’s moral teaching whenever the two diverge. They should, however, conform their own behavior to the Church’s standard.” With individuals, this kind of resolution usually suffices.

But Catholic institutions are another story: It is in their fortunes that Locke’s suspicions have proven most prescient. Roman Catholic schools have warred bitterly over their exemption from anti-discrimination employment statutes, scoring a win in a case argued before the Supreme Court as recently as this summer. Catholic hospitals have found themselves embroiled in court battles for refusing to perform or even discuss abortions, regardless of state or federal law. And, perhaps most famously, the Little Sisters of the Poor, an order of Catholic nuns that operates nursing homes for low-income seniors, fought the Affordable Care Act’s contraception mandate all the way to the Supreme Court, and won.

In each case, Catholic institutions have asked for exemptions to various laws, citing the First Amendment. In Lockean terms, they have argued that business putatively conducted in the civil sphere actually belongs to the religious one, and thus ought not be subject to the rules of civil government. They are staking out and reclaiming jurisdictional territory from the state, in other words, and each victory adds ground to the church’s domain.

There are those who worry that the exemption solution won’t work forever, and those who worry that it will work too well, shrinking the role of religion in public life and reducing the ranks of the faithful. There are also those, like me (I should note that I, too, am Catholic), who suspect that both may happen at once: that religions whose ethics conflict with the broader culture will shift toward forming small, dense enclaves, where they are unlikely to encounter legal challenges to their preferred practices. Evangelicals, for example, already predict this fate for themselves. But since the Roman Catholic Church is enormous, highly organized and financially capable of fighting for its ground to a much greater extent than other religious groups, cases concerning Catholic institutions will most likely continue cluttering court dockets for the foreseeable future.

It’s into this context that Ms. Barrett would step as a piously Catholic woman and a Supreme Court nominee. She neither created this situation nor will she end it; no justice placed on the bench could. It has a life and a legacy bigger than any individual cast in it by history, and it seems poised to keep us in shocking, surprising times.



Source link

READ ALSO

US to require negative COVID-19 test for air passengers traveling from UK

What's open Christmas Day 2020? CVS, Starbucks, McDonald's and 7-Eleven make the list but Walmart is closed

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT

Related Posts

US to require negative COVID-19 test for air passengers traveling from UK
New York Times

US to require negative COVID-19 test for air passengers traveling from UK

December 25, 2020
What's open Christmas Day 2020? CVS, Starbucks, McDonald's and 7-Eleven make the list but Walmart is closed
New York Times

What's open Christmas Day 2020? CVS, Starbucks, McDonald's and 7-Eleven make the list but Walmart is closed

December 25, 2020
Iowa cat home for Christmas after being lost for nearly 5 years
New York Times

Iowa cat home for Christmas after being lost for nearly 5 years

December 25, 2020
Officer who fatally shot unarmed Black man served with charges recommending his firing
New York Times

Officer who fatally shot unarmed Black man served with charges recommending his firing

December 25, 2020
NBA on Christmas Day viewer's guide: TV schedule, storylines and everything to know
New York Times

NBA on Christmas Day viewer's guide: TV schedule, storylines and everything to know

December 25, 2020
Alabama's Mac Jones and DeVonta Smith, Florida's Kyle Trask, Clemson's Trevor Lawrence named Heisman finalists
New York Times

Alabama's Mac Jones and DeVonta Smith, Florida's Kyle Trask, Clemson's Trevor Lawrence named Heisman finalists

December 25, 2020
Next Post
Opinion | Will Amy Coney Barrett Cost Republicans the Senate?

Opinion | Will Amy Coney Barrett Cost Republicans the Senate?

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

No Result
View All Result

Recent Posts

  • Military diet : जानिये इस सबसे आसान डाइट प्‍लान के बारे में, जो वजन घटाने में है मददगार
  • केप गूसबेरी या रसभरी है डायबिटीज के रोगियों के लिए वरदान, हम बता रहे हैं कैसे
  • Women’s health: Female patients to be asked about ‘gender health gap’
  • What is going on with government Covid contracts?
  • Covid-19: Vaccinated NHS staff numbers vary across England
  • Covid-19: Mystery UK person with Brazil variant found
  • Covid: Mental health money for children’s services
  • International Women’s Day: Illustrating the Covid-19 pandemic
  • वजन घटाने की बात हो या एक दमकती त्वचा पाने की, अभिनेत्री रकुल प्रीत सिंह देती हैं घी खाने की सलाह
  • Coronavirus infection levels continue to drop in the UK
  • Abaout Us
  • Contact Us
  • Disclaimer
  • DMCA
  • Privacy Policy

© 2021 JNews - Premium WordPress news & magazine theme by Jegtheme.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Diet & Fitness
  • Other
  • New York Times
  • UK News
  • माँ के नुस्खे
  • self-care
  • mental-health
  • feminine-hygiene
  • weight-loss

© 2021 JNews - Premium WordPress news & magazine theme by Jegtheme.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Create New Account!

Fill the forms below to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In